Banned documentaries

Banned documentaries


  • movieweb.com
  • Why was BBC’s documentary ‘India’s Daughter’ banned
  • After Karnataka HC order, Netflix blocks episode in crime documentary series
  • Kenya has banned a documentary for portraying a same-sex relationship
  • Anthony Watson banned following tweet posted while icing his knee
  • New documentary tells the story of how Franco banned Kubrick film ‘A Clockwork Orange’ in Spain
  • movieweb.com

    Their topics range from current events to crime investigations, sports and musical concerts. However, there are some filmmakers who are brave enough to create documentaries on highly controversial subjects that are told in a way that does not agree with the people in power.

    And more often than not, these documentaries are also banned. Here are six such controversial documentaries on Netflix, Amazon Prime Video and Vimeo that you must watch. This documentary went on to win several accolades, including an Oscar nod. However, in China, there was a blanket ban not just on the film but also on its creator Nanfu Wang. It was so brutal that when the Oscar nomination list was published in China, it left out Nanfu and her film.

    However, in India, this controversial film is available among the documentaries on Netflix, Amazon Prime Video and Vimeo. However, the controversial part about this story is that director Joshua Oppenheimer interviewed people for the film under the false pretense that he was doing so to make a film that praises their heroism.

    He even has several people, who were involved in this, re-enact the murders and due to this perception, the documentary was highly criticised for distorting the value of human life and violating their consent. The subject of this documentary is the Nirbhaya gangrape that took place in Delhi in It is still available on Vimeo but you have to be a member to watch it. Among all the controversial documentaries on Netflix, Amazon Prime Video and Vimeo, this will hit home the most.

    When released the following year in July, the censor board banned it on the grounds that it promoted communal disharmony among two religious sects and aroused unpleasant feelings between the two communities in question. It takes a look at the causes and the aftermath of the Muzaffarnagar riots through the eyes of the locals living there.

    However, it is available in Netflix to watch if the topic interests you. However, it attracted controversy as it was accused of massaging the egos of both Foos and Talese and portrayed these actions in a way that it diminished the crime, instead of giving a deeper perspective on how it impacted the victims.

    In their documentary, they not only meet families and children affected by this policy, but also touch up on the severe human trafficking prevalent in the country.

    Why was BBC’s documentary ‘India’s Daughter’ banned

    Disney doesn't want you to know how it started, but the creators say it's time. If you're no stranger to Disney home media, then you're aware of the cute things they'll put in their DVDs. You'll get the film's trailers, interviews with the cast, commentaries, and occasionally a documentary on the film's production.

    These documentaries are a classic way to promote the production of a movie, and they usually highlight the glamorous and fun parts of making it. But what if I told you that there was a documentary that Disney didn't want you to see? A documentary that didn't shy away from the warts and struggles that come with making a movie? That film would be The Sweatbox , which chronicled the production of a project titled Kingdom of the Sun, which would later transform into The Emperor's New Groove.

    Like all movies, The Emperor's New Groove started as an idea. Way back in Roger Allers, having just finished directing a little film called The Lion King, began working on a script. At the time, Disney executives were pushing for more culturally diverse stories leading to such films as Aladdin, Pocahontas and later Mulan , so the idea of a film with an Incan background seemed like another great idea. The story of Kingdom of the Sun follows a young llama herder with big dreams named Pacha and the emperor Manco Capac, who just wants to go out and have some fun without the watchful eyes of Yzma, the high priestess.

    After the two discover each other, Pacha offers to trade places with Manco for a night. But Yzma, who has been plotting to kill Manco for a ritual to restore her youth, catches him and accidentally gives him llama-potion instead of poison.

    Now the emperor is stuck as a llama and a llama herder is stuck playing the part of the emperor. The rest of the film chronicles their various hijinks, one learning humility, both finding love, and it all finishes off with a god of darkness being lassoed and destroyed. While the elements that end up becoming The Emperor's New Groove can be found in this initial plot, the film ends up bearing more of a resemblance to stories such as The Prince and the Pauper, as well as various nods to other Incan folk stories and mythology.

    And much in the style of Allers' previous Disney hit, The Lion King, a big-name musician was hired to help with the soundtrack of the film. Enter Sting. But Sting wanted something else out of involvement and a paycheck; he wanted a documentary on the project to be made with his wife, Trudie Styler, in the director's chair.

    Thus, production on The Sweatbox began. Allers stated in an interview with The Vulture. I met his wife Trudie.

    They were very gracious people. Pretty shortly after that, Trudie came up with the idea of doing a documentary about Sting's experience on a Disney film. She and her filmmaker J. Davidson would come periodically and canvass us, film things, interview people.

    They got to watch the whole up and down of the movie. See how a film can start in one direction and end in a completely different one, there's potential for sure.

    So here's the big question, why did Disney shelve this film that was practically ready to print and release? Well, the answers lie in the production story itself.

    Aller's initial story was a light hearted but ambitious, large scaled film. And Disney was dragging its feet after the big scaled box office failures that were Pocahontas and The Hunchback of Notre Dame. After those two movies lead with disappointing releases, the studio executives wanted to bring in a second director.

    Dindal's vision of the film was to lean more into the comedy elements while Aller tried to stick with the more epic and wider scaled themes. Many of the story artists felt that there was too much going on in the plot. Storyboard supervisor Steve Anderson, after a test screening of the original film, says this, "I remember people saying there's too many elements in the movie.

    It was The Prince and the Pauper. It was also the transformation of somebody into a llama. It was Yzma, who wants to raise the dead, snuff out the light, and have a world of darkness, but she also wants eternal youth and beauty. So it's like, okay, but which one does she want? Higher-ups began approving the the more light hearted direction and the power was beginning to shift.

    This caused tension in the workplace, as said by storyboard artist Chris Williams, "Up until that moment, it was clear what we're all trying to do, which is to support Roger and help him make his movie.

    Suddenly, my job changed. My job was now to work with Mark to try to help develop another movie, and we were competing with Roger. It was probably one of the most stressful periods of my life. So that was it, the film shifted from a big scale prince and the pauper story that was a love letter to Peru became a buddy comedy adventure. But it wasn't the end of the bumpy road for the crew. They had an entire movie to remake from the ground up with the same release date.

    There was also another issue, Sting wasn't happy with this new direction either. Executive producer Don Hahn stated, "Sting was a real mensch. When he saw the movie changing from the thing he signed up for, he sent a nice letter saying, "I didn't sign up for this, good luck. He was like, "Okay. We'll talk next week and then we'll send you the new assignment.

    In the end he had some really great work in the movie. But I think it's a difficult memory for him, because he wanted to do what Elton John did on Lion King. One rough moment in particular where Sting put his foot down was a deleted ending, which involved the newly named Emperor Kuzco levelling a nearby rainforest in order to build his Kuzco-topia.

    The ending was meant to play off as comedic, with Pacha and family keeping their home and the Emperor as a happy rich neighbor. Sting, a strong activist, stated in an interview with NME.

    I've spent 20 years trying to defend the rights of indigenous people and you're just marching over them to build a theme park. I will not be party to this. Nevertheless, though all the bumps and turns, the film was completed and released in December to a lower box office performance than what Disney was used to. There was a notably smaller marketing performance for the movie in favor of another film from the company coming out that Thanksgiving, Dalmations.

    The story behind Kingdom of the Sun and The Emperor's New Groove is a story of ambition, creatives persevering against the odds, and an eventual shift of power, The Sweatbox follows it through every hurdle. This is the biggest reason why Disney has yet to give the documentary a proper release. The film premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival on September , and had a few screenings after before fading into obscurity. A review on MotionPicturesComics. Com says this of the film.

    Meanwhile, we follow Sting and his collaborator David Hartley as they work to write and record six songs for the film. Then, about forty minutes in, we witness the fateful day in which an early story-boarded cut of the film is screened for the heads of Disney Feature Animation, Thomas Schumacher and Peter Schneider. They hate the film, declare that it is not working, and begin a process of totally scrapping and reinventing huge chunks of the story. Characters are totally changed the villager Pacha changes from a teenaged boy who looks just like the king into a heavyset married fortiesh man , voice actors are replaced, and the entire story is shifted around.

    The spoiled king once called Manco, now renamed Kuzco, but still voiced by David Spade becomes the main character. The epic saga becomes a small-scale buddy comedy. Director Roger Allers leaves the project, as do several lead animators. A Disney producer has to call super-star Sting to tell him that the six songs he's been working on for the past two years no longer work in the film, because they're about characters and story-lines that no longer exist, and they'd really love it if Sting would write some NEW songs for the film.

    It's a rough, professional look into the less magical realities that come with making a film, especially one from a studio as big as Disney.

    It is those exact points that the creators behind it want the film to finally see a proper release. The Sweatbox has become the finished movie Disney doesn't want you to see, transforming from what was supposed to be a promotional documentary to an intimate, hilarious, heartbreaking glimpse into what really happens behind the scenes of an animated project.

    It gets into the sweat and the grit of it all. Disney owns the thing. We don't have any clout in terms of releasing it ourselves. I would love to have released it. It pops up online now and then, and the lawyers take it back immediately. In , an unnamed individual leaked the completed documentary online. It has been circling the world in the form of Youtube uploads and torrents, only to be taken down by Disney lawyers and uploaded all over again.

    The film has gained an underground infamy because of this. Into the Unknown: Making Frozen II, a docu-series on the creation of the much-anticipated sequel to the smash hit Frozen, was very well received by viewers. There was also Howard, the documentary on the life of Disney composer Howard Ashman, which was critically praised upon release to the streaming service. Maybe it's about time The Sweatbox can be found among them.

    After Karnataka HC order, Netflix blocks episode in crime documentary series

    Please Vote For Me dir. They use bribery, blackmail, betrayal and fancy rhetoric to try to get elected. So about the same as adults. Yu Haibo, Yu Tianqi Kiki A hugely enjoyable documentary about the village of Dafen in the greater Shenzhen area, where peasants-turned-painters knock out replicas of Van Gogh and other Western artists.

    The action culminates in one of the oil painters traveling to Amsterdam to see his work on display for tourists to buy at a kiosk as well as the originals. China Gate Wang Yang Not to be confused with the Indian Curry Western and the s thriller of the same name, this well-made doc chronicles the travails of several students in the Chinese education system. The metaphor of the title is the gates or hoops that they must pass through in order to succeed, from the zhongkao high-school entrance exam to the gaokao college entrance exam.

    Up The Yangtze dir.

    Kenya has banned a documentary for portraying a same-sex relationship

    Petition dir. Zhao Liang A gripping fly-on-the-wall look at petitioners in Beijing seeking redress for their grievances at the hands of local officials. They travel hundreds or thousands of miles, wait for weeks or months, then often are callously turned away.

    Also check out Zhao Liangs doc on the coal industry, Behemoth, among his other work. Joshua: Teenager vs. Our former finance minister Arun Jaitley was confronted in an interview that the BBC documentary is violating the law of India as well as in England too.

    Anthony Watson banned following tweet posted while icing his knee

    Under Section A of IPC, the identification of the victim must not be exposed to the public, but the director was not concerned with our legislative system. This is clear infringing or ultra vires to our criminal law system. Because in that film the director had exposed the name of the victim as well as photographs of that victim. Indian procedures have been done, no doubt he would be prosecuted. Proprietary and law of allowing a forum to be made available to a rapist during the pendency of his trial and making this program available to him against why he is not guilty.

    Ironically, the accused appeal was pending at that time. The documentary was outlawed because there was a possibility of huge outrage in public. People with a criminal mindset may get influenced.

    New documentary tells the story of how Franco banned Kubrick film ‘A Clockwork Orange’ in Spain

    Some also criticized the purpose of the movie as being a little hazy. Feminist Activist Kavita Krishnan said that the film supports a very patriarchal aspect. Those videos of interviews had created so much offensive content as well as broken peace of public order. So to maintain peace and order, a petition was filed in Court to ban publishing and broadcasting the movie in India. No group or organization for their commercial benefit can not broadcast their documentary, we strongly condemn the incident of December 16, The director of BBC television, Danny Cohen stated that the corporation has given his ascent to show the film in the UK, by disregarding an approach from Indian Authority that it abolishes the broadcast.

    She added legal actions of India on kicking out the documentary had no feasible means. In the interview, Mukesh Singh had suggested she might have survived if she had not fought back. The authority of Tihar jail, who allowed her for the interview claimed that she had broken the contract by not permitting officials to assess her video clips. Udwin confessed to the BBC that she had written an application to the jail authority and they allowed her with proper guidelines.

    She added she had got signed permission from the Ministry of Home Affairs and the convicts as well. She told a news channel that she had submitted an edited version, which she has approved.

    She said she was convinced the ban on the movie would be overruled in the Delhi High Court. Public interest litigation was filed in Delhi High Court to elevate the ban, claiming that the ban on broadcasting is violating Article 19 in the Constitution Of India.

    Since the trial of the convicts was pending in the Supreme Court of Indiathe petition was denied on 12th March On March 20,the Supreme Court passed an order for the death sentence to those convicts. Issues raised by the documentary There are several issues raised by the controversial documentary through the Indian Government and The censor board has overshadowed the aim of the film and worldwide protests against it as well.

    Anyhow, the very crucial issues raised was gender discrimination, sexual harassment, some norms and folkways which violent crimes specifically against women. Another vital context was this movie may give voice to one of the unrepentant rapists. We live in a conservative society where girls are judged by the length of the skirt, with whom and what time she is roaming around.

    Education should be our priority to change this typical mindset. One should equally respect irrespective of the gender of the person. Every 20 minutes, a girl is raped in India. Despite having vast and exhaustive rules and regulations, laws are silent in this context. The defense lawyer A. P Singh also stated a very nauseated view on this sensitive event. Our sociological perception needs to be swapped regarding such troublesome and heinous consequences.

    Women are prejudiced here. A rape-free society is a utopia.


    thoughts on “Banned documentaries

    1. I apologise, but, in my opinion, you are mistaken. I can defend the position. Write to me in PM, we will talk.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *